Ditch the Dust: Unveiling the Power of Positive Law and Why It’s Actually Interesting!

Positive law jurisprudence, also known as legal positivism, delves into the nature of law as a set of human-made rules enforced by a sovereign authority. Unlike natural law theory, which posits a universal moral code underlying all legal systems, positive law focuses on the enforceable aspects of law, regardless of their morality.

Core Tenets of Positive law jurisprudence

  • Source of Law: Positive law emphasizes the origin of law in the commands of a legitimate authority, such as a legislature or judiciary. These commands are codified in statutes, regulations, and case law.
  • Validity vs. Morality: Positive law separates the concept of a law’s validity from its moral content. A law is considered valid if it’s enacted through the proper procedures, regardless of its ethical implications.
  • Sovereignty and Legitimacy: The concept of sovereignty plays a crucial role. A sovereign is the entity with the ultimate authority to create and enforce laws within a particular jurisdiction. Legitimacy refers to the law’s acceptance by the governed, either through consent or established power structures.

Prominent Thinkers in Positive law jurisprudence

  • Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832): A founder of legal positivism, Bentham emphasized utility as the basis of law. Laws should be judged by their effectiveness in promoting the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people.
  • John Austin (1790-1859): Austin defined law as a command issued by a sovereign, backed by the threat of sanction. He distinguished positive law from morality and divine law.
  • H.L.A. Hart (1907-1992): A 20th-century legal positivist, Hart distinguished between primary rules (rules that govern behavior) and secondary rules (rules that empower officials to create, enforce, and adjudicate primary rules).

Positive Law vs. Natural Law: A Classic Debate

certainly Positive law jurisprudence stands in opposition to natural law theory. Natural law posits a universal moral code that transcends human-made laws. Proponents of natural law argue that unjust positive laws can be challenged based on their deviation from this higher moral code.

Here’s a table summarizing the key differences of positive and natural law jurisprudence:

FeaturePositive LawNatural Law
Source of LawHuman-made rulesUniversal moral code
FocusValidity and enforceabilityMorality and justice
Relationship between Law and MoralityLaw can be independent of moralityLaw should reflect morality
Mhaagj Web Industry Jurisprudence blogs archive https://mhaagj.org/category/laws-blog/jurisprudence/

Contemporary Relevance of Positive Law philosophy

Positive law jurisprudence remains a dominant school of thought in legal theory. It provides a clear framework for understanding the operation of legal systems and the role of law in society. Here are some key aspects of its contemporary relevance:

  • Understanding Legal Systems: Positive law helps us analyze and interpret laws based on their formal sources and procedures, promoting stability and predictability within legal systems.
  • Challenging Unjust Laws: While positive law doesn’t inherently require morality, legal positivists acknowledge the need to reform unjust laws. Positive law creates a framework for legal change through legislative processes and judicial review.

Positive law jurisprudence, despite its focus on the “law as is,” doesn’t preclude discussions of the “law as it ought to be.” It provides a foundation for legal reasoning while acknowledging the ongoing debate about the ideal relationship between law and morality.

Positive law jurisprudence

Additional Reading on Positive law jurisprudence

  1. Jeremy Bentham and the Foundations of Classical Legal Positivism: Dissecting the Command of the Sovereign
  2. Understanding Kelsen’s Pure Theory of Law! A Detail Blog with pdf
  3. The Evolution of Jurisprudence: From Ancient Roots to Modern Theories.

1 thought on “Ditch the Dust: Unveiling the Power of Positive Law and Why It’s Actually Interesting!”

Leave a Reply

Discover more from AbdiPress Legal knowledge Website

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top